Failing to grasp capitalism

7fe0f17d-a5b6-42f7-b14e-37730747cdd1

Good to see that the alarmists have moved the “saving the planet” argument to repairing 5yo washing machines. 35 years ago, repairing a VHS deck was worth the money. A new deck would set one back multiples of the repair. Can one honestly say they would bother repairing a 5yo deck when the replacement is likely to be near as makes no difference the same, if not cheaper than the repair?

Did the BBC think to measure that a brand new washing machine might consume a quarter of the electricity and half the water of a 5yo one? Over 100s or washes it would pay for its own environmental footprint many times over.

Perhaps the regulators trying to gather momentum behind this ‘grand’ proposal  might let the free market determine whether people would bother to repair a broken appliance based on cost. If they felt compelled to revive a 5yo for the cost of a replacement then so be it. Chances are, like flat screen TVs, capitalism will have brought the cost of a like for like new LED 4K to a quarter of what it cost 5 years ago.

Perhaps Brussels can establish an entire building dedicated to subsidized repair jobs. Spend billions in infrastructure to cater to a question no one is asking

The EU regulators are trying to force manufacturers to make appliances last longer. If a consumer wants to buy a cheap Chinese made fridge and run the risk of it dying too soon, why stop them? If another shopper thinks paying 3x for a fancy Made in Japan fridge on the basis it might last longer, why not let them choose?

Going by the EU directive surely car makers should offer 20 year warranties. Although doesn’t it contradict the push to eradicate fossil fuel sales by 2040. Doesn’t forcing child slave labour in Africa to mine the cobalt to go in batteries propose deeper ethical questions?

Ultimately market forces can quickly determine whether repair is feasible. No need to mandate makers to build equipment that consumers aren’t demanding.

Rest assured people! The EU once launched multi year study on whether water rehydrated or not. Instead of accepting it, the EU introduced laws which prosecuted companies that claimed its water products did! Go figure? It’s journalism like this that makes one think they’re all eating Tide pods.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s