Pension Sinkhole


The pension problem that many in the US face is no laughing matter. ‘Tis but a scratch is how many (especially state run) pension funds continue to view their predicament outwardly. Internally they must be panicking. Actuarial accounting is a wonderful thing. Tweak a few assumptions and immediately wash away a deep deficit. To put this in perspective the California Public Employee Retirement System (CalPERS) lost around 2% of its funds in 2015/16. The fund assumes an aggressive 7.5% return. Dr. Joe Nation of Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research thinks unfunded liabilities have surged to $150bn from $93bn in the last two years. Furthermore suggesting the use of a more realistic 4% rate of return. CalPERS has an unfunded liability of $412bn (or the equivalent of 3 years’ worth of state revenue). California collects $138bn in taxes annually in a $2.3 trillion economy (around the size of Italy). With over-inflated asset markets and increasingly negative returns on highly rated paper, the growth in unfunded liabilities is even more concerning as any market correction (likely to be severe given such blatant manipulation to date). If the correction is huge it will push the unfunded portion to even more dizzying levels.

According to a Bureau of Labor Statistics report from 2015, the average household income of someone older than age 75 is $34,097 and their average expenses are around $34,382. Despite such austerity, a pension collapse would literally kill off the ability to live a bare bones existence.

Years of poor investments have stuffed South Carolina’s government pension plans with a massive funding gap. The plans serve about 550,000 (11%) of residents, and the shortfall of $24.1 billion is more than 3x Palmetto State’s annual budget.

Rewind to 2008. The municipality of Vallejo, California filed for bankruptcy. It wasn’t just the evil bankers that caused financial markets to collapse resulting in tax revenues shrivelling. Sadly, the city of Vallejo was living high on the hog. Bloated pensions and fat cat salaries for public servants ruled by stubborn unions created a scenario where it could not bail water fast enough when the crash hit.

The police captain was paid over US$300,000 while his lieutenants were on c.US$250,000. The average fire fighter took home US$170,000. The police and firefighters pay and conditions sucked up three-quarters of the budget much more than the 55-60% of most municipalities. That $80mn budget suddenly faced a $17mn black hole.

The city was forced to fire 40% of its 260 police officers and told its residents to be judicious with calling 911. Crime rates soared above the state average.

Vallejo did not sort its pension obligations to CalPERS during its bankruptcy negotiations which ended up becoming its largest budget hole by a considerable margin. Even in 2011 when the city came out of bankruptcy the pension time bomb ticked away. Moreover, the declaration of bankruptcy prevented access to bond financing making budget gap filling even more complicated.

Fast forward to 2016, the anaemic (and slowing) economic growth around the world is putting stress on pension funds ability to payout retirees and fund future pensions. Pension funds set “return targets” which actuaries calculate to ensure the fund stays solvent. However, pension funds need to be diversified with a mixture of cash, bonds and equities. With equities reaching more outlandish valuations and bonds moving further into negative yield territory (capital appreciating at least) pension fund returns are undershooting. When pension funds undershoot then the unfunded liabilities keep growing. As more baby boomers retire the more outflows are putting more pressure on the unfunded portions.

San Bernardino, California also filed for bankruptcy after GFC carrying $140mn in unfunded pension liabilities including $50mn in debt it had to raise to fill the pension hole. Yes! It was borrowing money to plug a pension hole. Sort of like buying groceries on the credit card you can’t pay off.

Take Detroit, Michigan. It declared bankruptcy around this time three years ago. Its pension and healthcare obligations total north of US$10bn or 4x its annual budget. Accumulated deficits are 7x larger than collections. Dr. Wayne Winegarden of George Mason University wrote that in 2011 half of those occupying the city’s 305,000 properties didn’t pay tax. Almost 80,000 were unoccupied meaning no revenue in the door. Over the three years post the GFC Detroit’s population plunged from 1.8mn to 700,000 putting even more pressure on the shrinking tax base.


Scroll forward to 2013 and this is how it looks. 2017 would look even more terrible.


Do people then rely on Social Security? Well, according to the 2016 Social Security Trustees report it shows at the current rate the Social Security’s combined retirement and disability trust funds will be empty by 2034. The trustees estimate that the 75-year shortfall is $11.4 trillion in NPV terms. Good luck filling that.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s